What Questions Should I Ask My Car Accident Attorney?

February 9, 2024
What Questions Should I Ask My Car Accident Attorney?

Accidents on the road happen when you least expect them. These crashes are an unfortunate reality of modern life whether you drive a car or ride as a passenger. When an accident occurs, it can leave victims in pain, out of work, and with no idea of how to proceed. Suppose you have been in an accident. In that case, you may face a lot of uncertainty but must maintain a clear head to make crucial decisions regarding your medical treatment and legal issues surrounding your case. That is why you may soon realize that you need the assistance of an attorney after a car accident. “But how do I hire the right attorney?” you may wonder. Understandably, with so many law firms available in your area, choosing an attorney may feel like an arduous task. Fortunately, there is a way to ensure that you can find an car accident attorney who will do an excellent job on your case: you must ask the right questions.

Schedule a Free Initial Consultation

Questions to Ask a Car Accident Attorney

When researching car accident attorneys in your area, compile a list of attorneys who fit your specific criteria. Then, feel free to schedule a consultation or meet with them to ask as many relevant questions as possible. Your questions can ensure you find the right attorney for your case. Below, we put together a list of questions that can guide you in evaluating an attorney’s qualifications and getting a sense of their ability to provide the representation you need:

How long have you practiced law in my state?

Different states have different laws and regulations regarding car accidents, so your attorney must have relevant experience practicing law in your state. This familiarity will ensure they are confident with the laws and regulations that apply to your case and can use that knowledge to your advantage.

Do you have experience handling similar cases?

Experience is everything when handling car accident cases, no matter how trivial they may seem. For this reason, you need an attorney who has successfully handled similar cases to yours and knows the local laws and regulations like the back of their hand. They know how to navigate the legal procedures in a streamlined manner and can get the results you deserve.

Why do you think I have a good case?

You want to know your prospective attorney’s stand on your case and if they think you have a good chance of winning. A knowledgeable attorney will be honest with you and give you a realistic picture of your options. They will also explain the evidence needed to build a strong case and what you must do as the claimant throughout the process.

How should I handle the insurance company and its adjuster?

Insurance companies can be tricky to deal with, and their adjusters always strive to protect the company’s interests rather than yours. A solid car accident attorney knows how to communicate with the insurance company and its representatives to command respect, give you the best possible representation, and maximize your recovery.

What damages can I recover?

After analyzing the facts of your case, a skilled attorney can outline the types of damages that are recoverable under the law. “Damages” refer to the money the injured party is permitted to recover from the negligent party. These damages may include but are not limited to medical expenses, lost income, diminished earning capacity, emotional trauma, and property damage. An estimate of what compensation you can seek will give you a better understanding of what your case is worth.

How much do you charge for your services?

It is essential to understand the attorney’s fees and payment structure. Some attorneys charge a flat fee, while others charge a percentage of the settlement amount. Some also handle cases on a contingency fee basis, when the client does not pay anything unless the attorney wins. A reasonable attorney will explain their billing structure and how it works, giving you the transparency you need to make an informed decision about the choice of your attorney.

How long do you think my case will take?

Understanding the timeline of your case will give you a sense of how long you will be dealing with the legal process and how soon you can expect financial compensation. While every case is unique, an experienced attorney can give you an estimate based on the circumstances surrounding your case accident.

Will you be working on my case, or will it be someone else in your firm?

As a client, you deserve to know who will handle your case because you want to establish a productive relationship with your attorney. If the person you are talking to plans to pass your case off to someone else in their firm, you will also want to meet with that person. Knowing who will handle your case and having a relationship with them can make the legal process much smoother.

What fees and costs will I be responsible for?

Money can be a sensitive topic, especially when you have medical bills and income loss. Still, knowing what fees and costs you will be responsible for before and after hiring an attorney and throughout your case is vital. Reputable car accident lawyers work on a contingency basis, and you should discuss how this fee arrangement works.

What do I do if the insurance company makes an offer?

Insurance companies often try to make offers to settle a claimant’s case in the first hours or days after the accident. However, before accepting such an offer, you need to know whether or not it is fair. Your attorney can advise whether to take the offer or pursue further legal action. Knowing what to do in this situation can make all the difference in the outcome of your case.

How can I improve the chances of success for my case?

This question is essential because it sets the groundwork for your case. A good attorney can tell you what you need to do to improve your chances of winning based on experience. They should provide specific advice on documentation, evidence gathering, witness interviews, and more.

Will my case go to trial?

While most car accident cases do not go to court, some may require a trial. An experienced attorney can estimate how likely your case will go to trial so that you can start preparing accordingly. If a trial is looming, you must consider factors such as the time, cost, and emotional strain involved in the litigation process.

How often will we communicate?

Communication is crucial in any attorney-client relationship. Your attorney should be available to answer your questions and keep you in the loop every step of the process. Find out how often you can expect to hear from them and their preferred means of communication. Some attorneys are more accessible than others, so it helps to know whether you can contact them via email, phone, or in-person meetings.

What deadlines should I be aware of?

In any legal case, deadlines are critical, and missing them can be detrimental to the outcome of your case. Ask your attorney about the applicable deadlines in your case, including filing paperwork, responding to discovery requests, filing a lawsuit, and other critical dates and timeframes. Your attorney can give you an overview of the timeline involved in your case and what you need to do to meet crucial deadlines. Fact: For example, in Florida, injured victims have two years from the date of their injury to bring a lawsuit (Fla. Stat. § 95.11).

What case strategy will you be implementing?

Before you start working with an attorney, you need to know the strategy they have in mind for your case. In other words, what approach will they take to ensure you receive the best outcome possible? An effective attorney can explain their strategy and its reasons, providing a better idea of what to anticipate during your case.

What are the strengths and weaknesses of my case?

Your attorney needs to evaluate the strengths and weaknesses of your case to determine if you have a strong chance of winning. They can also identify any problem areas in your case and develop strategies to address them adequately. Ask your attorney to identify any obstacles and potential outcomes; knowing these things upfront will prepare you for what’s to come.

How should I pay for my medical bills while my case is pending?

Car accident injuries are costly, and medical bills are one of the most prominent expenses you might incur after a car accident. Your insurance company may not cover all your medical expenses, so you must know how to pay for them while your case is still pending. Ask your attorney if they can recommend any medical providers who accept a lien or medical lien funding. You may receive medical treatment immediately without any upfront payments and pay your medical bills after the settlement or verdict of your case.

What information and documents do you need from me?

Your attorney will need specific information and documents regarding your car accident to start working on your case. It’s essential to keep all documentation of your accident organized, including police reports, photos, and medical bills or reports. Having everything on hand during your initial consultation can help your attorney review the case better.

How much time do you have to devote to my case?

Some car accident attorneys have high caseloads and may be unable to devote as much time as you want. Ask your attorney how much time they can attribute to your case and if they have any upcoming cases that may interfere. If your attorney works in a law firm, ask if they plan to assign some parts of your case to a paralegal. Knowing this information gives you an idea of what to expect.
Chris Castillo, Attorney for Car Accident
Chris Castillo, Car Accident Attorney

Top Qualities of the Best Car Accident Lawyer

In addition to asking questions, you should also ensure that your attorney possesses a combination of personal and professional qualities, such as:
  • The ability to listen to the client and understand their needs - An attorney should be an excellent listener and have the ability to sincerely empathize with their clients’ situations and understand their needs. They should take the time to listen to their client’s stories and concerns and develop a plan tailored to their specific case needs.
  • Empathy for the clients and a genuine interest in helping them - Ideally, an attorney should demonstrate a sincere desire to help clients through all challenges on their path to recovery. They should show empathy and be committed to doing whatever it takes to secure the best possible outcome for every client.
  • A strong work ethic - A top-notch car accident attorney should be diligent and hardworking, putting in the time and effort needed to strengthen the client’s case. They should work tirelessly to gather evidence, prepare legal briefs, negotiate with insurance companies and other parties, and present compelling arguments in court.
  • Clear and concise communication - An attorney must communicate clearly and effectively. They should explain the legal process simply and provide regular updates on their clients’ cases.
  • Responsiveness and approachability - The best car accident lawyers should be approachable, accessible, and responsive to their clients’ needs. They should promptly return calls, emails, and other communications, be available to answer questions, and provide guidance throughout the legal process.
  • Masterful negotiation skills - Excellent negotiating skills are one of an attorney's top traits when settling car accident cases outside court. You must look for an attorney who can negotiate persuasively on your behalf to obtain a fair settlement.
  • Attention to detail - Details matter in every car accident case. A great attorney will strive to be meticulous in their approach, leaving no stone unturned when preparing a winning case for their clients.
  • A proven track record of success - Last but not least, choosing a car accident lawyer with a history of winning both in and outside court is crucial. A client should give preference to an attorney with experience handling similar cases.
If you can find a personal injury attorney who possesses all these traits, that is great. Hire them without thinking twice. However, it is rare – and, in many cases, unrealistic – to expect your attorney to have all these qualities. For this reason, choose an attorney with the most characteristics that are essential to you.

Schedule a Free Initial Consultation Today!